Supreme Court Report

Supreme Court of the United States

The Counsel Table


Who files certiorari petitions, whose petitions get a second look, and whose get granted — across OT2017–OT2025.

Terms: OT2017–OT2025

Every paid petition docketed in the archive with a named petitioner’s counsel of record: 10,049 petitions from 5,066 advocates, filed in 9,912 separate cases. The bar is long-tailed — 3,675 advocates (73%) appear exactly once — so an advocate needs at least 5 cases to appear below, and 317 clear that bar. The two tables that publish a rate ask for 8, which 152 reach: at five, eleven of the twenty-five relist rows were the same three-of-five advocate.

This counts petitioner’s counsel of record and nothing else. An advocate who argued a case they did not petition in does not appear, and respondents’ counsel — which is most of what the Supreme Court bar actually does — is invisible here. The amici, and the lawyers who write for them, are on a page of their own.

Volume

Most cases filed

Companion petitions are counted once: a single dispute is often docketed as several petitions, and counting each one credits an advocate with eight filings for one case.

AdvocateCasesRelistedGranted
1Paul D. Clement1183826
2Elizabeth B. PrelogarGovernmentElizabeth B. Prelogar / Elizabeth Barchas Prelogar905847
3Noel J. FranciscoGovernmentNoel Francisco / Noel G. Francisco / Noel J. Francisco / Noel John Francisco673526
4Kannon K. Shanmugam652116
5Neal Kumar KatyalNeal K. Katyal / Neal Kumar Katyal59167
6Mithun MansinghaniGovernment56422
7Robert L. Sirianni Jr.Robert L. Sirianni / Robert L. Sirianni Jr.5610
8Raed GonzalezRaed Gonzalez / Raed Gonzalez, Esq.5591
9D. John SauerGovernment502618
10E. Joshua Rosenkranz4866
11John J. Bursch44124
12Gregory George GarreGregory G. Garre / Gregory George Garre4244
13Lisa S. BlattLisa S. Blatt / Lisa Schiavo Blatt411314
14Paul Whitfield HughesPaul Hughes / Paul W. Hughes / Paul Whitfield Hughes3785
15Andrew Timothy TuttAndrew T. Tutt / Andrew Timothy Tutt3764
16Seth P. Waxman3773
17Shay Dvoretzky34109
18Jeffrey L. Fisher34108
19Stuart Banner3332
20Carter G. Phillips2922
21Dennis P. Derrick2900
22Erick G. Kaardal2800
23Daniel L. Geyser2779
24Adam G. Unikowsky2676
25David H. ThompsonDavid Clark Thompson III / David H. Thompson26124

A second look

Most often relisted

A relist is a redistribution with no intervening “Rescheduled” entry, no call for a response and no CVSG — those are mechanical rather than the Justices deferring. Published as a share, not a count: the raw count correlates with filing volume at 0.81 and would simply re-rank the table above. Ordered by the lower bound (the muted figure), not the share.

AdvocateCasesRelistedShare
1Mithun MansinghaniGovernment564275%62%
2Elizabeth B. PrelogarGovernmentElizabeth B. Prelogar / Elizabeth Barchas Prelogar905864%54%
3Sarah M. HarrisGovernmentSarah M. Harris / Sarah Michelle Harris / Sarah Michelle Harris III11873%43%
4Noel J. FranciscoGovernmentNoel Francisco / Noel G. Francisco / Noel J. Francisco / Noel John Francisco673552%40%
5D. John SauerGovernment502652%39%
6David H. ThompsonDavid Clark Thompson III / David H. Thompson261246%29%
7Christina Marie MartinChristina M. Martin / Christina Marie Martin11655%28%
8Allyson HoAllyson Ho / Allyson N. Ho9556%27%
9Paul D. Clement1183832%24%
10David J. ZimmerDavid J. Zimmer / David Jacob Zimmer / David Zimmer10550%24%
11Kannon K. Shanmugam652132%22%
12Jeffrey B. Wall20840%22%
13Thomas M. Fisher11545%21%
14Lisa S. BlattLisa S. Blatt / Lisa Schiavo Blatt411332%20%
15Amanda Kelly RiceAmanda K. Rice / Amanda Kelly Rice / Amanda Rice9444%19%
16Patrick Michael JaicomoPatrick M. Jaicomo / Patrick Michael Jaicomo9444%19%
17Neal Kumar KatyalNeal K. Katyal / Neal Kumar Katyal591627%17%
18Jeffrey Alan LamkenJeffrey A. Lamken / Jeffrey Alan Lamken21733%17%
19Jeffrey L. Fisher341029%17%
20Shay Dvoretzky341029%17%
21Theane Evangelis Kapur10440%17%
22Roman Martinez VRoman Martinez / Roman Martinez V22732%16%
23John J. Bursch441227%16%
24Donald B. Verrilli Jr.Donald B. Verrilli / Donald B. Verrilli Jr.19632%15%
25Andrew Michael GrossmanAndrew M. Grossman / Andrew Michael Grossman11436%15%

Certiorari granted

Whose petitions are granted

48.4%
For the United States
188 cases
14.9%
For a State
228 cases
4.6%
For a private party
9,310 cases

Which is why there are two boards rather than one. A pooled grant ranking would be the Solicitor General’s office at the top, and that measures who the client is, not how the petition was written. The split is made case by case, so an advocate who did both work appears on both boards.

For a private client

Ranked by the lower bound of a 95% confidence interval on the grant rate, with the rate itself shown in bold. Ranking on the raw rate instead puts 3 grants in 10 above 22 in 94 — a higher number on a tenth of the evidence.

AdvocateCasesGrantedRate
1Lisa S. BlattLisa S. Blatt / Lisa Schiavo Blatt401435.0%22.1%
2Daniel L. Geyser27933.3%18.6%
3Andrew John PincusAndrew J. Pincus / Andrew John Pincus14535.7%16.3%
4Shay Dvoretzky32928.1%15.6%
5Paul D. Clement1102421.8%15.1%
6Kannon K. Shanmugam631523.8%15.0%
7Matthew Dempsey McGillMatthew D. McGill / Matthew Dempsey McGill8337.5%13.7%
8Jeffrey L. Fisher34823.5%12.4%
9Adam G. Unikowsky25624.0%11.5%
10Mark Andrew PerryMark A. Perry / Mark Andrew Perry / Mark Perry10330.0%10.8%
11Roman Martinez VRoman Martinez / Roman Martinez V21523.8%10.6%
12Andrew Michael GrossmanAndrew M. Grossman / Andrew Michael Grossman11327.3%9.7%
13Jessica Lynn EllsworthJessica L. Ellsworth / Jessica Lynn Ellsworth11327.3%9.7%
14Michael A. Carvin11327.3%9.7%
15Jeffrey Alan LamkenJeffrey A. Lamken / Jeffrey Alan Lamken21419.0%7.7%
16Allon Kedem8225.0%7.1%
17David H. ThompsonDavid Clark Thompson III / David H. Thompson24416.7%6.7%
18Aaron Michael StreettAaron Michael Streett / Aaron Streett9222.2%6.3%
19Allyson HoAllyson Ho / Allyson N. Ho9222.2%6.3%
20Melissa Arbus Sherry9222.2%6.3%
21Robert James McNamaraRobert J. McNamara / Robert James McNamara9222.2%6.3%
22Xiao Wang9222.2%6.3%
23Paul Whitfield HughesPaul Hughes / Paul W. Hughes / Paul Whitfield Hughes36513.9%6.1%
24Neal Kumar KatyalNeal K. Katyal / Neal Kumar Katyal58712.1%6.0%
25E. Joshua Rosenkranz48612.5%5.9%

For a government

Federal and state governments together — 4 advocates clear the minimum on government cases alone.

AdvocateCasesGrantedRate
1Elizabeth B. PrelogarElizabeth B. Prelogar / Elizabeth Barchas Prelogar784152.6%41.6%
2Noel J. FranciscoNoel Francisco / Noel G. Francisco / Noel J. Francisco / Noel John Francisco472246.8%33.3%
3D. John Sauer331339.4%24.7%
4Mithun Mansinghani4712.1%0.4%

Against expectation

Grants the case alone did not predict

A grant rate cannot tell an advocate who wins from one who is handed winnable cases. So each private-bar advocate’s grants are set against what the site’s cert model expects of the same petitions once it is told nothing about counsel: who the parties are, the court below, how fast the petition was filed, whether it reports a dissent or a split, and how long it is. Each Term is scored by a model fitted on the others, then shifted as a whole so its expected grants match the number the Court actually made that Term — how many cases the Court takes is no advocate’s doing. Over 9,311 private cases from OT2017–OT2025 it expected 463 grants and there were 431; dropping counsel costs it little (AUC 0.876 with counsel, 0.867 without).

AdvocateCasesGrantedExpectedRatio
1Lisa S. BlattLisa S. Blatt / Lisa Schiavo Blatt40143.73.8×2.8×
2Kannon K. Shanmugam63154.83.1×2.5×
3Shay Dvoretzky3292.83.2×2.3×
4Andrew John PincusAndrew J. Pincus / Andrew John Pincus1451.14.7×2.3×
5Jeffrey L. Fisher3482.53.2×2.2×
6Daniel L. Geyser2793.62.5×2.0×
7Paul D. Clement1102411.82.0×1.9×
8E. Joshua Rosenkranz4862.32.6×1.9×
9Jeffrey Alan LamkenJeffrey A. Lamken / Jeffrey Alan Lamken2141.42.9×1.8×
10Roman Martinez VRoman Martinez / Roman Martinez V2152.42.1×1.6×
11Paul Whitfield HughesPaul Hughes / Paul W. Hughes / Paul Whitfield Hughes3652.42.1×1.6×
12Jessica Lynn EllsworthJessica L. Ellsworth / Jessica Lynn Ellsworth1131.22.4×1.5×
13Andrew Timothy TuttAndrew T. Tutt / Andrew Timothy Tutt3742.41.7×1.4×
14Lawrence David RosenbergLawrence D. Rosenberg / Lawrence David Rosenberg2421.11.9×1.3×
15Michael Hugh McGinleyMichael H. McGinley / Michael Hugh McGinley1121.11.9×1.3×
16Eric Schnapper1921.11.9×1.3×
17Michael B. KimberlyMichael B. Kimberly / MIchael B. Kimberly2431.91.6×1.3×
18Adam G. Unikowsky2564.21.4×1.3×
19David C. Frederick1921.11.7×1.3×
20Donald B. Verrilli Jr.Donald B. Verrilli / Donald B. Verrilli Jr.1821.21.7×1.3×
21Stuart Banner3021.31.6×1.2×
22Neal Kumar KatyalNeal K. Katyal / Neal Kumar Katyal5875.51.3×1.2×
23Carter G. Phillips2721.41.5×1.2×
24Gregory George GarreGregory G. Garre / Gregory George Garre3843.31.2×1.1×
25Seth P. Waxman3732.41.2×1.1×

The ratio is grants divided by the expectation. The board is ordered by the muted figure, the same ratio with 2 expected grants’ worth of “as expected” mixed in, so that 2 grants against 0.2 does not outrank 13 against 3.3. 49 advocates have 8 or more scored cases and at least 1 expected grant. Measured in standard errors, their results spread 1.8 wide; chance alone would give 1.0. Above expectation is not the same as skill. Leading advocates are often retained once a case already looks worth granting, for reasons the docket does not record, and the model credits the case with anything counsel put into the petition it reads.

At the lectern

Who argues

A different question, from a different record: the docket names the advocate who actually stood up, and the side they stood on. 498 arguments in 496 cases by 500 advocates, February 2018 to April 2026 — 59 of them argued 5 or more times. Companion cases argued together count once. An argument made as amicus counts here and nowhere below: the judgment ran for or against the parties, and an amicus is neither. OT2017’s arguments are incomplete: the archive begins with the cases docketed in OT2017, so the OT2016 cases heard in OT2017 — most of that Term’s arguments — are not here.

AdvocateArgumentsFor pet’rFor resp’tWon
1Paul D. Clement3626925 of 34
2Malcolm L. StewartSG’s Office2919814 of 27
3Elizabeth B. PrelogarSG’s OfficeElizabeth B. Prelogar / Elizabeth Barchas Prelogar29111413 of 24
4Eric J. FeiginSG’s Office2571613 of 20
5Lisa S. BlattLisa S. Blatt / Lisa Schiavo Blatt22121011 of 20
6Edwin S. KneedlerSG’s OfficeEdwin S. Kneedler / Edwin Smiley Kneedler221277 of 18
7Jeffrey B. WallSG’s Office2011313 of 14
8Noel J. FranciscoSG’s OfficeNoel Francisco / Noel G. Francisco / Noel J. Francisco / Noel John Francisco191537 of 14
9Frederick LiuSG’s Office17599 of 14
10Kannon K. Shanmugam171439 of 15
11Neal Kumar KatyalNeal K. Katyal / Neal Kumar Katyal17885 of 14
12Shay Dvoretzky171065 of 16
13Anthony A. YangSG’s OfficeAnthony A. Yang / Anthony Yang169711 of 16
14Sopan JoshiSG’s Office16759 of 12
15Jeffrey L. Fisher161158 of 16
16Daniel L. Geyser15966 of 13
17Erica L. RossSG’s OfficeErica L. Ross / Erica Ross14567 of 11
18Vivek SuriSG’s Office14656 of 11
19Curtis E. GannonSG’s Office13939 of 12
20Matthew GuarnieriSG’s Office13398 of 12
21Sarah M. HarrisSG’s OfficeSarah M. Harris / Sarah Michelle Harris / Sarah Michelle Harris III121018 of 11
22David C. Frederick12392 of 12
23Michael R. HustonSG’s OfficeMichael Huston / Michael R. Huston / Michael Robert Huston11647 of 10
24Colleen R. SinzdakSG’s OfficeColleen E. R. Sinzdak / Colleen E. Roh Sinzdak / Colleen E. Sinzdak / Colleen Elizabeth Roh Sinzdak / Colleen R. Sinzdak11655 of 10
25Brian H. FletcherSG’s OfficeBrian H. Fletcher / Brian Halligan Fletcher11644 of 9

Winning, against a Court that reverses

73.8%
Arguing for the petitioner
606 arguments
32.4%
Arguing for the respondent
528 arguments

The Court takes cases in order to reverse them — case by case it did so in 70% of the 461 cases scored here — so which side of the “v.” an advocate stood on matters more than anything they said. A pooled ranking would mostly sort advocates by that, and its top would be the Solicitor General’s office, which chooses the cases in which the United States petitions. So the record is split in two and each board is read against its own figure above.

Those two figures do not add to 100%, because they are rates over arguments rather than two halves of one case. A side can send more than one advocate to the lectern, and the side that wins usually does; and in 15 cases the judgment below was defended by a court-appointed amicus, who has no client and is not scored, so the petitioner’s win has no counterpart. The judgment below either stood or it did not: it stood on an affirmance and on a dismissed appeal, it fell on a reversal or vacatur. 18 arguments ended in a split judgment or a writ dismissed as improvidently granted and are scored for neither side.

Arguing for the petitioner

AdvocateArgumentsWonRate
1Paul D. Clement262492%76%
2Jeffrey B. WallSG’s Office1111100%74%
3Curtis E. GannonSG’s Office99100%70%
4Hashim M. MooppanSG’s Office77100%65%
5Jonathan Y. EllisSG’s OfficeJonathan Ellis / Jonathan Y. Ellis / Jonathan Yates Ellis66100%61%
6Michael R. HustonSG’s OfficeMichael Huston / Michael R. Huston / Michael Robert Huston66100%61%
7Aimee W. BrownSG’s OfficeAimee Brown / Aimee W. Brown55100%57%
8Eric J. FeiginSG’s Office55100%57%
9Anthony A. YangSG’s OfficeAnthony A. Yang / Anthony Yang9889%56%
10Elizabeth B. PrelogarSG’s OfficeElizabeth B. Prelogar / Elizabeth Barchas Prelogar11982%52%
11Sarah M. HarrisSG’s OfficeSarah M. Harris / Sarah Michelle Harris / Sarah Michelle Harris III10880%49%
12Roman Martinez VRoman Martinez / Roman Martinez V7686%49%
13Malcolm L. StewartSG’s Office191368%46%
14Seth P. Waxman6583%44%
15Lisa S. BlattLisa S. Blatt / Lisa Schiavo Blatt10770%40%

Arguing for the respondent

AdvocateArgumentsWonRate
1Jonathan C. BondSG’s OfficeJonathan C. Bond / Jonathan Charles Bond8675%41%
2Sopan JoshiSG’s Office5480%38%
3Eric J. FeiginSG’s Office15853%30%
4Frederick LiuSG’s Office9556%27%
5Matthew GuarnieriSG’s Office9556%27%
6Nicole F. ReavesSG’s OfficeNicole F. Reaves / Nicole Reaves5360%23%
7Austin RaynorSG’s OfficeAustin L. Raynor / Austin Raynor6350%19%
8Erica L. RossSG’s OfficeErica L. Ross / Erica Ross6350%19%
9Lisa S. BlattLisa S. Blatt / Lisa Schiavo Blatt10440%17%
10Anthony A. YangSG’s OfficeAnthony A. Yang / Anthony Yang7343%16%
11Elizabeth B. PrelogarSG’s OfficeElizabeth B. Prelogar / Elizabeth Barchas Prelogar13431%13%
12Aaron L. NielsonStateAaron L. Nielson / Aaron Lloyd Nielson5240%12%
13Benjamin W. SnyderSG’s OfficeBenjamin Snyder / Benjamin W. Snyder / Benjamin William Snyder5240%12%
14Vivek SuriSG’s Office5240%12%
15Jeffrey L. Fisher5120%4%

The strongest 15 records on each side, of 30 and 22 advocates who argued 5 or more times for that side. These are records inside this window, not careers — several of the advocates here have argued well over a hundred cases, and a handful of arguments on one side of the “v.” is a small sample of anyone.

How to read this

An advocate here is a name, not a verified identity. Rows are keyed on a first and last name, so “Neal K. Katyal” and “Neal Kumar Katyal” merge — and so would two different lawyers who share both names. Every row that merged more than one spelling prints them beneath the name so the merge is visible. The dockets carry no firm, so there is nothing else to disambiguate on.

Whether a petition was filed for a government is read from the petitioner’s name, never from the case caption — a private petitioner suing the government has the government in their caption. That test almost never calls a private petition governmental, but it misses roughly one government petition in six, so an advocate who files for a government in at least a quarter of their cases is kept off the private board entirely rather than appearing on it with whatever the test failed to catch.

Paid petitions docketed OT2017–OT2025, through June 30, 2026. Self-represented petitioners are excluded. Pending petitions count toward cases filed and relists but not toward a grant rate.

Each fact belongs to the Term in which it happened. A petition belongs to the Term it was docketed — 24-1287 is OT2024 — and an argument to the Term it was heard, so a case granted late in one Term is counted at the petition stage in that Term and at the lectern in the next. The argument and judgment entries for a Term’s granted cases appear after that Term’s archive was taken, so they are read from a re-fetch of the argued grants. An advocate can therefore appear at the lectern without appearing above it — much of the Solicitor General’s office argues cases it did not petition in — and the counts are of arguments made, not of cases won for a client.

← Supreme Court Report