Dennis D. Baillargeon v. Brendan T. Carroll, Esq., et al.

Whether a criminal defendant's due process rights under the Fourteenth Amendment are violated when a prosecutor, in direct response to the trial court's inquiry into what remains to be disclosed to the defense, gives an answer that omits material information the prosecutor already possesses — here, that previously available video evidence had become unavailable — where that omission occurs at the precise moment the court is deciding whether to grant a continuance, and forecloses the defendant's ability to seek that continuance on its true and more compelling ground.