John W. Orem, et ux. v. Matthew Gillmore, et al.

Whether the Respondent State Trooper’s lack of probable cause to search was sufficiently clear, when all reasonable inferences are made in Petitioner’s favor, to pierce qualified immunity and subject him to liability under 42 USC § 1983 for violating Petitioner’s 4th Amendment Rights. Whether the Respondent State Trooper’s lack of probable cause to arrest was sufficiently clear, when all reasonable inferences are made in Petitioner’s favor, to pierce qualified immunity and subject him to liability under 42 USC § 1983 for violating Petitioner’s 4th Amendment Rights. Whether the Fourth Circuit erred in upholding the District Court’s finding that Petitioner had no evidence upon which to proceed to a jury trial regarding his invasion of privacy claim. Whether Petitioner had a Constitutional right to privacy in the circumstances surrounding his medical emergency.